My comment this morning is not related to this article although this was valuable. I’m somewhat upset after waking up this morning and finding out that President Trump addressed a group in Grand Island Nebraska and during his so-called campaign rally, he suggested that Iran take out LA and San Diego as they were not valuable cities. This absolutely got to my core. I am so upset. I cannot believe an American president would speak this way to a group of people. The president represents every citizen in America and to think he’s involved in a war with a Ron right now and says they have been obliterated of all of their weapons and yet he’s telling them to go ahead and take out two valuable cities in our country. Who talks like this? This sounds like a person that is very dangerous and deranged. I cannot believe that people are not upset this morning whether you’re a republican or a democrat this absolutely is no way for an American president to speak to people, and I can’t understand why people are not calling him out this morning.
The comments he makes get worse every day. He is the most unprofessional president we have ever had. I’m trying to understand what other countries think about America when our own president speaks like this about the very people he’s trusted to take care of and look out for their well-being. Obviously, I’m upset this morning. I’ll get off my soapbox and maybe you can provide some insight to us today …thank you.
And just as appalling was the applause he got from his audience after saying that. What is wrong with so many of our fellow citizens that they would give approval of such an awful remark?
Agreed. I do wonder, though, how much Trump is scraping from the bottom of his voter base in his rallies these days. If you're still crazy enough to believe his actions are for the betterment of the country, you are significantly lost and I don't think you'll ever get to reality with the rest of us. Not an excuse, but I do think theses are the worst of the worst.
Ignorance, bigotry, hatred, lack of education, poor critical thinking skills, life inside a bubble of disinformation, identity issues and lack of individuality, desire from acceptance by equally ignorant (whether willful or due to lack of factual data), or --mostly, I think-- gullibility (how many of his worshippers TRULY believe what he says?).
I like "The Good Liars," and I hope that someday after they ask "what has Trump done, specifically, that's helped you?" and get the evasive and conveniently-forgetful responses of "a lot of things...but I can't think of one now," they will ask if the cultist knows how to get to Shell Beach. (Not sure how obscure the "Dark City" reference is; but those who have seen it might see the dark humor.)
Remember that unlike you and I, Republicans care NOTHING for our Constitution and laws, think children are sex toys, believe that your wallet belongs to them and that the king should spend tax revenue as only HE sees fit, that the king is above our laws (as are those who serve him), and that America should exist in isolation as an all-White walled garden where no allies nor trade are needed and that women should STFU and go have babies to be useful. I don't understand how they got there, but they are how WE got HERE.
Vote them ALL out, and let's promote AMERICAN values instead of REPUBLICAN "values."
Spot on. Indeed, it’s been 45 years+ in the making. We just weren’t paying close enough attention. The Dems especially weren’t paying close enough attention.
Could be; but also likely that they wouldn't care, as long as Dear Leader's goals were served and he was properly worshipped. "They lived in Libtard California: they got whut wuz comin' to 'em!" would be a likely response by his base.
Yesss! Tracy, I was appalled at the gleeful, clapping crowd when Trump made this statement. WTH is the matter with these people??? Do they not realize that their city or town could be named next as you never know with this man. He’s a terrible human and president.
Thank you, Cynthia! I have to admit that the appalling comment you mentioned ("he suggested that Iran take out LA and San Diego as they were not valuable cities") was one that I missed. It is now obvious that this wretched man must be removed, if not by the 25th Amendment (not likely), then by a BLUE WAVE in November. Thanks, again! 👍🙇♂️
The words I think of when I think of Trump aren't fit to print here. Safe to save he's immoral, he's dumb (with a B!), and he's unfit.
This morning I heard Thom Tillis hawking his book about sycophants (mirror?). He put the blame on Noem and Hegseth, for example, but HE supported both. Any FOOL could see that neither of these people was fit to serve as a Cabinet Secretary. He blamed "bad" advice/advisors on the current situation with immigration, war, and the economy - The President is getting bad advice. Has he MET Donald Trump? Trump doesn't listen to ANYONE who doesn't echo what he already thinks.
Glad he's leaving the Senate. I hope that he's wrong and MAGA loses the Senate along with the House.
Th-om is walking a tightrope here: while he WANTS to keep his connections with the RepubliCult so that he can profit from them next year as a lobbyist once he's no longer trying to destroy our country and violate our Constitution from INSIDE our government, he must also appear to his NON-cult constituents to be sorta kinda American (a little: not enough to worry the RepubliCult that he might start demanding they follow the Constitution and laws, but enough to seem to AMERICANS like he might actually honor our Constitution and laws SOMEDAY). If he upsets the cultists, he can't maximize his post-Congressional income by becoming one of the rich lobbyists like the ones who own him now (remember how Bondi made a fortune working for other countries after ignoring Trump/Epstein's crimes when she was AG of FL but BEFORE ignoring Trump/Epstein's crimes as AG of the USA?); and if he upsets enough AMERICANS in his constituency, he might get tarred and feathered and run out of town for his work to sabotage our nation's democracy and government.
But, like all Republicans, the projection is real; and despite his lockstep voting with Trump and the cult, he'll spin all of this as somehow not HIS fault, despite voting for ALL OF IT (including violating our Constitution JUST to vote for the illegitimate insurrectionist...and don't tell me a two-term (12 years!) SENATOR somehow doesn't know what the 14th Amendment says about needing a 2/3 vote to allow an insurrectionist to hold office ever again.)
I felt a similar outrage about the letter he enclosed when he sent $90 to seniors. A complete and total lie and disparaging name calling for democrats. And we paid to have the lie sent out and to be called names. WTH.
You got a check??? I did not - curious who is getting them. I would send it back because I think it's ridiculous and a bribe, but I haven't been given that opportunity!
I didn’t get one, either. If I did, I’d send it to Al-Sayed! I don’t agree with him on everything, but I still think he’s a great candidate who will open an important dialogue.
https://youtu.be/QmkD4M0FVTo?si=E7J6soCxkn-qjplV I received my $90 directly to my bank account yesterday. Medicare. Congress has had this money for years. Long before DT was elected. As usual, he is trying to take credit. Idiot.
Probably is spam. Watch the the u-tube video around the 1:40 mark. Didn't get any text messages or email regarding this refund. Automatically deposited in my account. Text notices U are receiving are probably a scam.
They went to senior citizens on SS...I got it deposited in my account and couldn't figure out why at first, because it came from SS...Then I remembered what he said...I didn't get a letter of any kind, just the deposit.
I am in a financial crisis, and he has never done a thing that helped me, so I am keeping it and using it. (Laid off, just diagnosed with breast cancer. It wasn't much of a bribe for pete's sake; I wonder who came up with that amount.
It is hard to decipher what is more troubling, a president who continually spews hate and revenge, saying things like the LA and San Diego comment, calling a senatorial candidate “ Tranny Annie” because of her support for children and gender, “ shove it up there ass” in reference to the Republican need to win the mid terms, touting himself as the man who knows more about anything than anyone else, what is to me equally or more troubling are the people who cheer and support this cruel and disgraceful administration…our country is so angry, so divided, healing will be a long process
It should read Iran, not Ron. I was so upset I couldn’t type so I used the microphone and apparently it didn’t pick it up and I didn’t catch it before I submitted it.
This has always been his attitude: he only bothers to pretend to serve those who worship him; and has never hidden his hatred for any who voice criticism or opposition , or support our laws and Constitution, or report truthfully on his corruption and incompetence, or are darker the "ecru" on the ICE/Gestapo/Kavanaugh Guilt-determining Color Swatch or are female, or serve in our military, or are Capitol Police...
FOUR WEEKS until midterms: make a plan to vote, and don't be afraid to ask OTHERS to vote, as well. Americans outnumber Republicans 2:1, so LET'S TAKE BACK OUR NATION and return to being Constitutional and respecting laws that apply to EVERYONE (even the very richest and most powerful pedophiles in and with connection to the 2/3 of the remaining White House).
PS I see some people (who liked Cythia Wiese comment). still somehow think TRUMP will be normal one day. He wont, he is what you see and he would love IRAN to Bomb LA AND SAN DIEGO! It is not shocking in any way ...that is who he and Stephen Miller are. FASCISTS to the core.
You are absolutely right. It’s appalling. I just heard about this about an hour ago and couldn’t believe it.
And it’s not off topic. It absolutely speaks to the topic. This is not a reaction that requires a partisan or party-specific response. It affects anyone and everyone regardless of their political stripes.
San Diego can lean more conservative, but according to Il Duce, they’re in the nuclear crosshairs. Happily so, by his reckoning.
You’re from Nebraska, which is the second – unintentional – point that’s not tangential. The Dems have rallied behind Dan Osborn, an Independent. I’ve heard him in an interview, and I think the coalition needs folks like him. I certainly don’t agree with everything he says, but I do believe he needs space under the tent.
It’s not the first time that he’s talked about a nuclear strike on an American city, but now he’s gotten more specific. The President ruminates on these things, stays up all night “truthing” or whatever it’s called. Now that Newsom has spoken out, it’s going to get worse.
Iran can’t hit us with a nuclear weapon of course, but given the fact that he’s threatened to pull FEMA response for blue states in the past, counter terrorism support for states not complying with requests to turn over voter rolls, and has a severely diminished stockpile of defensive weapons, I think the biggest threat is that he would deprioritize their defense in the event of an attack by an aggressor. Not that we should expect that, but we have a president who probably would do that. No other president would make someone like myself even have to consider such scenarios.
I am one of those Independents who can’t stand Trump but I am also leery of some Democratic positions. The Democratic Party is the vehicle we must use to rid ourselves of MAGA.
I appreciate your comment about the Dems being "the vehicle we must use to rid ourselves of MAGA". I'm a registered, lifelong Democrat, and while I'm excited about many of their programs, I'm clear-eyed about their weaknesses as well. One thing I know for sure: I will stay on my state and federal representatives to deliver on their promises.
I actually got the phrase about the Democratic Party being “the vehicle” from Sarah Longwell of The Bulwark. I am listening to her book How to Eat an Elephant. I recommend it.
We just criticize Democrats extremely carelessly. Not only do we not back up our criticism with solid arguments, we indulge (and for SO long already) in just claiming vague stuff the way you do here, without even THINKING of being precise in our criticism.
Cynicism on the left is one of the main reasons why we ended up here in the first place.
So with that... what are those "weaknesses" more precisely?
Sheesh, slow your roll! I don't think saying that the Dems have weaknesses is extreme criticizing! Believe me, I know what extreme criticizing is as I've been doing it regarding Trump and the Republican party for a steady 12 years. Also, I'm not about to add to a quick acknowledgenent reply with details of what I mean by weaknesses. Every person, animal, organization, etc. on earth, in this dimension and time has weaknesses. We do not live in perfection.
See, you're doing it again: you blindly repeat that "Dems have weaknesses," you even add that you are "clear-eyed" about that, and then... give NO concrete example of such a weakness, let alone arguments to prove that this would be true. Even after someone asks you to give at least one example.
Why not?
Why just spread more cynicism and blind Dem-bashing? You really think that's needed, especially today?
I learned not to take the bait. His handle means “Excuse Us We Don’t Talk Back”. It’s true, he doesn’t talk back, he condescends and likes to poke the bear. A troll really.
He just fiercely defends the Dems, refusing to acknowledge their serious shortcomings. And how they, too have failed the Working and Middle Class in many ways. Which is why so many were sent hurtling into the arms of Rump. Millions of whom were former Democrats.
He requests examples from others, yet offers none himself for his ardent support of the Democratic Party.
Fortunately, he’s really the only one I have ever seen here behaving this way.
There is a large group on the left that doesn't vote for the Democratic candidate, because it isn't the candidate they liked the most. That is a significant weakness. We have weaknesses in messaging. We sometimes lack the courage to stand up for groups when they are unfairly marginalized by the right. We sometimes lack the courage to stand up TO groups that are demanding unreasonable concessions to earn their vote. Etc. Fortunately, we don't have the most significant weakness: we don't have a leader of our party that has completely dissolved our morals, ideologies, and ability to make American lives better. That should make everyone in the middle and left very proud.
In a primary, sometimes your candidate wins and sometimes they lose. We have to accept that and continually put in efforts to bring people closer to our ideals. Just remember, plenty of others doing the same thing.
I’ve never heard this. Interesting. I VBNMW. Because I have no other choice. Well I had Bernie, but the Dems buried him—twice. Because they have become too establishment themselves. And way too Corporate.
FYI for everyone concerned about AIPAC/Israel funding our representatives. Keep in mind, many of these people are excellent representatives and it costs money to stay in office. Some of the names may surprise you while others won’t, I’m sure. The point is right now is to hang together or we shall surely hang separately. I think old Ben Franklin is credited with having said that. Keep in mind, those guys were having many of the same arguments we are having today in spite of the fact that they would be considered and treated as traitors to the crown.
Name the Democratic party positions you are uncomfortable with, it is not hard to be specific, it is too easy to just say you are “leery of some Democratic positions.”
I do believe this—no, I KNOW this about the Biden Administration! Accusations and calling people intellectually lazy is no way to start a conversation. This is the polar opposite of what this very article is about…El-Sayed went into enemy territory to talk with people who are completely propagandized by that very platform. He spoke with reason, calmness and clarity. He didn’t go on there and tell them how “intellectually lazy” they are.
Damn dude, try a different tack. The idea is to reach people, converse, exchange ideas…not condescend and attack.
Intellectual laziness is real. Why would we try to put our head in the sand rather than tackling the problem and solving it?
As to El-Sayed: yes, when talking with "the enemy", diplomacy is THE priority. But here, we're talking among ourselves. So here we can and should get real, no? If not here, then where... ?
Also "intellectual laziness" refers to an ACTION (or whole series of actions). Not any particular person. It's precisely the tendency to take disagreements personally these days/years that makes real debates impossible.
But we all owe it to society as a whole and democracy.
Individualism and democracy are not compatible.
THE key rule of engaging in a real debate is that you ALWAYS accept to not just spout "personal opinions" (which often are just what the dominant culture tells us to think) but to accept to fact-check your OWN opinions, as soon as someone asks you, by showing evidence that backs them up.
If YOU make the claim, YOU need to tell us what evidence you discovered that proves it.
Someone who disagrees with that claim by definition cannot do it, because IF he discovered the same evidence, he might not disagree in the first place.
A democracy vitally requires constant education by and for citizens. That practice is almost entirely gone today, including on the left.
I think a little history is required here. I. Have been registered Republican who often voted democratic. The Bill Clinton abortion platform turned me off.
Since January 6th I am an independent which is nice in California
Because she is supposed to copy and paste it for YOU. I see, but she (annd others) are intellectually lazy. M’k. Who’s being being emotional rather than rational now? 🤔
You can’t just go check it out? That’s what I did. I’d never even heard of it. Great stuff. I just subscribed.
Just another reason why we need more than just 2 viable parties. For that to work we need to get rid of the Electoral College. The Democrats have always created a platform at their conventions. The Republicans in the Trump era didn’t bother with a platform. It was literally “whatever Trump wants.” This week in Illinois RepublicanJim Durkin, former House Minority Leader in the state legislature, endorsed Democratic governor JB Pritzger over his Republican opponent Darren Bailey. It’s an encouraging sign that support for Trump is fading and affecting elections at all levels.
Independent until the two-party system is improved. I don't align well with either party, but I don't fault them for that - we need to find a better way to distinguish different groups in a coalition so that moderate Republicans can feel comfortable working/voting with moderate dems. That's not meant to be a slight against Progressives - I just think it's a shame that the entire party is viewed from the same lens, when it's a WIDE range of viewpoints.
Reread what Adam wrote. We can have those discussions later. Right now the goal is to recognize the collective danger that Trump poses and join together to start getting a rope around his(fill in the blank)to stop him from any further damage.
Well said. Perfect example is the coalition of countries that got together to stop Hitler. Like you said we need countries on are side, something Hegsbreath doesn’t understand.
Yes. There was once a time when there were liberal and progressive Republicans and conservative Democrats. The result was a much more dynamic process of building ad-hoc coalitions to address particular things. Right now we need a coalition to preserve democracy.
Great column. We surely need a large and wide ranging coalition of people who want to ensure that democracy reigns here. A coalition of any and all who believe in our constitution and the rule of law. A coalition of people who remember what is what like when their immigrant families came here and struggled for a better way of life. A coalition of people who believe that our allies are valuable and essential to preserving a just peace. A coalition of people who believe that stealing, violating ethics standards and self dealing in office goes against the oath of office one took for the privilege of holding public office. These basic tenets are neither right nor left . I’ve said before that this country has a big tent open to many different people and opinions . There is a place for anyone and everyone of good will.
Yes, we absolutely need an "uncomfortably big coalition".
Next, we need to get comfortable with disagreements and learn to engage in real, respectful debates rather than running away as soon as someone disagrees with us.
Recently a fellow progressive told me, when we disagreed about an actually pretty minor thing, "I choose not to engage on this topic any further". That was before she gave ANY argument backing up her claim.
This is not okay. For far too long, progressives have forgotten how to HONOR healthy disagreements and engage with them. That is on us. No MAGA cult ever forced us to do so. It's also on us to urgently drop this intellectual laziness and get real again, especially now that democracy itself depends on it!
Exactly! And ALL of us, since none of us possess The Truth.
If we stop engaging in debates about politics at home, at work, at church etc, we contribute to a collective dumbing down of society as a whole, which cannot but lead to political and other disasters.
Democracy vitally needs disagreements AND constant debating of those disagreements.
Not a culture that instead values emotional reactivity...
Exactly! All too often today, the media claim that the US is so "divided", but that seems to mostly refer to the fact that there are a lot of disagreements.
Disagreements are GOOD, in a democracy - including inside one party (even more so when there are only two parties).
Real "division" only arises when we refuse to back up our claims with arguments and evidence or adopt a "post-truth" attitude where everyone has the "right" to believe whatever they want, no questions asked.
Example: apparently Jennifer Dyke already blocked me (making it impossible for me to see and therefore reply to other people replying to my posts in the same thread), ONLY because I asked for arguments backing up her claims (as a fellow Democrat, moreover).
That literally divides us, and can never lead to anything good.
I totally agree we need respectful debates. This morning I read about 2 men in Ohio in a dog park whose disagreement about our president ended in gunfire and now potentially prison for an 80 year old man. The 3rd man trying to break up the fight said he doubted that it actually changed either of their opinions. We have to do better and have meaningful conversations about our thoughts and ideas.
Adam, you're so right when you say "none of those differences are as big as the threat in front of us"... you're either for democracy and the rule of law, or you're not ... I welcome anyone for the first one!
Thank you Adam for this post, and for illuminating the need Dr. El-Sayid talks about, in building a broader coalition. I also appreciate Dr El-Sayid’s reference to the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Although Dr. El-Sayid mis-attributed a specific quote to Dr. King, the legacy of Dr. King was all about inclusion. In 1960, there were people in the civil rights movement who disagreed with his commitment to nonviolence. When challenged, Dr King said, “There can be unity when there isn’t uniformity.” His point was that people could differ over how to pursue change while still unite in the struggle for it.
These people are and have been committing treason against The United States. I do not see any other way to look at this. There is no way any of the other Presidents would have made such a statement. Taking out an American city? Good God.
Well, if the spineless and anti-Constitution Republican "party" didn't have a problem with Trump's failed coup, nor with electing him in direct violation of the 14th Amendment, nor with confirming his Klown Kar Kabinet, nor with him assuming Article I powers, nor with him straight-up stealing from our Treasury, nor with him taking emoluments for the 6 years in the Oval, nor with him fielding a Gestapo that kills Americans and others in the street with impunity, nor with Bribe Jet One/East Wing-Epstein Ballroom/Reflecting Pool/Arc de Pedo/campaign ads on the taxpayer dollar/kidnapping a foreign leader and making his nation a colony to extract oil and gold from, threatening ALLIES with annexation or invasion, backstabbing Ukraine and NATO, removing sanctions on Russia as they give satellite and targeting info to Iran to kill our troops, gutting the government, .......
I would encourage everyone to find a bridging organization and learn how to talk across the aisle (or even within your aisle). I moderate workshops for Braver Angels and I see the magic that happens when we lean into the discomfort and learn to disagree better. Let’s make a bigger tent where all perspectives are welcomed and disagreement leads to better solutions, not more contempt.
Thanks, Adam, for this post. As a left-leaning independent, I am not always comfortable with Dem proposals, but we are facing a choice between democracy and dictatorship. That is not a choice. So, squabble about policy later, but right now it is essential the Democratic tent includes everyone who is taking a stand against the authoritarianism currently supported by what remains of the GOP. I grew up in a Goldwater-right Republican family, but by 1980 I voted for John Anderson, and I have been unimpressed by the two parties ever since. But that has not kept me ftom voting - ever - and has made me research the people for whom I have voted. It's only been since 2016 that I have voted only for Dems, since I've concluded anyone choosing to run as a Republican is demonstrating spectacularly bad judgment. This election and 2028 are too important to the continuance of our republic to vote for a Republican candidate in any race. I truly hope that a new Republican party devoid of the influence of trump (more importantly devoid of the Project 2025 cabal) emerges in the next few years so that we actually have options. But that's not the case this year.
You wrote "It's only been since 2016 that I have voted only for Dems". That logically entails that in 2010, you still voted for at least some Republicans, no?
Ah....I may have voted for a Rep in a local race. I don't remember. But since trump's first term, I have not found a GOP candidate in any race I could support because running as a GOP candidate means they accept trump - and that makes their judgment flawed.
Don’t forget that Pete Buttigieg went on Fox a lot to try to reach that audience. Syed is not the first one to do it. Pete needs to be acknowledged for that too.
There’s a phenomenon called the narcissism of small differences that addresses how like- minded groups can fragment over less important differences in values, preferences, opinions, issues etc.
Take as an example religious sects fighting over relatively minor differences in interpretations of scripture.
In a sense it’s losing sight of the forest for the trees. We need to be cognizant of this and strive to not let it divide us.
Currently in the world there is some form of universal healthcare in 54 out of 195 countries. Those numbers may be plus or minus one or two, but it does show that universal healthcare is something our country should work toward. There are a lot of progressive ideas that I do agree with, but there are also some that I do not agree with. You are right, Mr. Kinzinger, the party isn't the coalition. Right now, I would say that many of us whether we are republican, democrat or independent see that what we are fighting against is so much more than party politics. The Heritage Foundation's Project 2025 is probably about 75% done, and if we want to keep our Democracy, it cannot be allowed to come to completion. If that should happen, we can kiss our Democracy good-bye. Currently, America is being viewed as a country in collapse, divided and weak. It is sad that our once great country is being viewed that way, and as far as I am concerned, the fault lies squarely on the shoulders of the man in the White House, his cabinet and all the republicans that have allowed him to destroy us. I will never stop fighting against authoritarianism. Thank you. That was an excellent post today, Mr. Kinzinger!
My comment this morning is not related to this article although this was valuable. I’m somewhat upset after waking up this morning and finding out that President Trump addressed a group in Grand Island Nebraska and during his so-called campaign rally, he suggested that Iran take out LA and San Diego as they were not valuable cities. This absolutely got to my core. I am so upset. I cannot believe an American president would speak this way to a group of people. The president represents every citizen in America and to think he’s involved in a war with a Ron right now and says they have been obliterated of all of their weapons and yet he’s telling them to go ahead and take out two valuable cities in our country. Who talks like this? This sounds like a person that is very dangerous and deranged. I cannot believe that people are not upset this morning whether you’re a republican or a democrat this absolutely is no way for an American president to speak to people, and I can’t understand why people are not calling him out this morning.
The comments he makes get worse every day. He is the most unprofessional president we have ever had. I’m trying to understand what other countries think about America when our own president speaks like this about the very people he’s trusted to take care of and look out for their well-being. Obviously, I’m upset this morning. I’ll get off my soapbox and maybe you can provide some insight to us today …thank you.
It’s so disgusting
And just as appalling was the applause he got from his audience after saying that. What is wrong with so many of our fellow citizens that they would give approval of such an awful remark?
Agreed. I do wonder, though, how much Trump is scraping from the bottom of his voter base in his rallies these days. If you're still crazy enough to believe his actions are for the betterment of the country, you are significantly lost and I don't think you'll ever get to reality with the rest of us. Not an excuse, but I do think theses are the worst of the worst.
The "basket of deplorables," front and center.
Ignorance, bigotry, hatred, lack of education, poor critical thinking skills, life inside a bubble of disinformation, identity issues and lack of individuality, desire from acceptance by equally ignorant (whether willful or due to lack of factual data), or --mostly, I think-- gullibility (how many of his worshippers TRULY believe what he says?).
I like "The Good Liars," and I hope that someday after they ask "what has Trump done, specifically, that's helped you?" and get the evasive and conveniently-forgetful responses of "a lot of things...but I can't think of one now," they will ask if the cultist knows how to get to Shell Beach. (Not sure how obscure the "Dark City" reference is; but those who have seen it might see the dark humor.)
Remember that unlike you and I, Republicans care NOTHING for our Constitution and laws, think children are sex toys, believe that your wallet belongs to them and that the king should spend tax revenue as only HE sees fit, that the king is above our laws (as are those who serve him), and that America should exist in isolation as an all-White walled garden where no allies nor trade are needed and that women should STFU and go have babies to be useful. I don't understand how they got there, but they are how WE got HERE.
Vote them ALL out, and let's promote AMERICAN values instead of REPUBLICAN "values."
Spot on. Indeed, it’s been 45 years+ in the making. We just weren’t paying close enough attention. The Dems especially weren’t paying close enough attention.
Could it be possible that those people who clapped have not one relative or friend in Los Angeles or San Diego?
Could be; but also likely that they wouldn't care, as long as Dear Leader's goals were served and he was properly worshipped. "They lived in Libtard California: they got whut wuz comin' to 'em!" would be a likely response by his base.
Yesss! Tracy, I was appalled at the gleeful, clapping crowd when Trump made this statement. WTH is the matter with these people??? Do they not realize that their city or town could be named next as you never know with this man. He’s a terrible human and president.
Thank you, Cynthia! I have to admit that the appalling comment you mentioned ("he suggested that Iran take out LA and San Diego as they were not valuable cities") was one that I missed. It is now obvious that this wretched man must be removed, if not by the 25th Amendment (not likely), then by a BLUE WAVE in November. Thanks, again! 👍🙇♂️
The words I think of when I think of Trump aren't fit to print here. Safe to save he's immoral, he's dumb (with a B!), and he's unfit.
This morning I heard Thom Tillis hawking his book about sycophants (mirror?). He put the blame on Noem and Hegseth, for example, but HE supported both. Any FOOL could see that neither of these people was fit to serve as a Cabinet Secretary. He blamed "bad" advice/advisors on the current situation with immigration, war, and the economy - The President is getting bad advice. Has he MET Donald Trump? Trump doesn't listen to ANYONE who doesn't echo what he already thinks.
Glad he's leaving the Senate. I hope that he's wrong and MAGA loses the Senate along with the House.
Th-om is walking a tightrope here: while he WANTS to keep his connections with the RepubliCult so that he can profit from them next year as a lobbyist once he's no longer trying to destroy our country and violate our Constitution from INSIDE our government, he must also appear to his NON-cult constituents to be sorta kinda American (a little: not enough to worry the RepubliCult that he might start demanding they follow the Constitution and laws, but enough to seem to AMERICANS like he might actually honor our Constitution and laws SOMEDAY). If he upsets the cultists, he can't maximize his post-Congressional income by becoming one of the rich lobbyists like the ones who own him now (remember how Bondi made a fortune working for other countries after ignoring Trump/Epstein's crimes when she was AG of FL but BEFORE ignoring Trump/Epstein's crimes as AG of the USA?); and if he upsets enough AMERICANS in his constituency, he might get tarred and feathered and run out of town for his work to sabotage our nation's democracy and government.
But, like all Republicans, the projection is real; and despite his lockstep voting with Trump and the cult, he'll spin all of this as somehow not HIS fault, despite voting for ALL OF IT (including violating our Constitution JUST to vote for the illegitimate insurrectionist...and don't tell me a two-term (12 years!) SENATOR somehow doesn't know what the 14th Amendment says about needing a 2/3 vote to allow an insurrectionist to hold office ever again.)
Oh Eva, I will supply a word for you….Fuckwit!!
I felt a similar outrage about the letter he enclosed when he sent $90 to seniors. A complete and total lie and disparaging name calling for democrats. And we paid to have the lie sent out and to be called names. WTH.
You got a check??? I did not - curious who is getting them. I would send it back because I think it's ridiculous and a bribe, but I haven't been given that opportunity!
I'd give it to a Democratic candidate's campaign fund...
Exactly!!!
I didn’t get one, either. If I did, I’d send it to Al-Sayed! I don’t agree with him on everything, but I still think he’s a great candidate who will open an important dialogue.
Send the money to a candidate, like Talerico!
https://youtu.be/QmkD4M0FVTo?si=E7J6soCxkn-qjplV I received my $90 directly to my bank account yesterday. Medicare. Congress has had this money for years. Long before DT was elected. As usual, he is trying to take credit. Idiot.
Everytime I received a text notice about this check I deleted it and marked it spam
Probably is spam. Watch the the u-tube video around the 1:40 mark. Didn't get any text messages or email regarding this refund. Automatically deposited in my account. Text notices U are receiving are probably a scam.
https://youtu.be/QmkD4M0FVTo?si=E7J6soCxkn-qjplV
Figured it out - if you have a Medicare Advantage plan, you don't qualify, so it's a non-issue for me.
They went to senior citizens on SS...I got it deposited in my account and couldn't figure out why at first, because it came from SS...Then I remembered what he said...I didn't get a letter of any kind, just the deposit.
I am in a financial crisis, and he has never done a thing that helped me, so I am keeping it and using it. (Laid off, just diagnosed with breast cancer. It wasn't much of a bribe for pete's sake; I wonder who came up with that amount.
So sorry you're going thru so much - and this message doesn't help! Use the money!!!
It isn’t easy having a traitor for president.
But it was far too easy for him to get there.
It is hard to decipher what is more troubling, a president who continually spews hate and revenge, saying things like the LA and San Diego comment, calling a senatorial candidate “ Tranny Annie” because of her support for children and gender, “ shove it up there ass” in reference to the Republican need to win the mid terms, touting himself as the man who knows more about anything than anyone else, what is to me equally or more troubling are the people who cheer and support this cruel and disgraceful administration…our country is so angry, so divided, healing will be a long process
It should read Iran, not Ron. I was so upset I couldn’t type so I used the microphone and apparently it didn’t pick it up and I didn’t catch it before I submitted it.
And then they were the people in Trump’s audience who cheered when he said takeout Los Angeles and takeout San Diego. They are worse than he is.
Other countries are in shock and stupefied. Other ALLIED countries. Their citizenry lambastes us daily. As we deserve.
Russia, China, N. Korea are having a field day. As are our even hate us more now enemies in the Middle East. Which we rightly deserve as well.
This has always been his attitude: he only bothers to pretend to serve those who worship him; and has never hidden his hatred for any who voice criticism or opposition , or support our laws and Constitution, or report truthfully on his corruption and incompetence, or are darker the "ecru" on the ICE/Gestapo/Kavanaugh Guilt-determining Color Swatch or are female, or serve in our military, or are Capitol Police...
FOUR WEEKS until midterms: make a plan to vote, and don't be afraid to ask OTHERS to vote, as well. Americans outnumber Republicans 2:1, so LET'S TAKE BACK OUR NATION and return to being Constitutional and respecting laws that apply to EVERYONE (even the very richest and most powerful pedophiles in and with connection to the 2/3 of the remaining White House).
PS I see some people (who liked Cythia Wiese comment). still somehow think TRUMP will be normal one day. He wont, he is what you see and he would love IRAN to Bomb LA AND SAN DIEGO! It is not shocking in any way ...that is who he and Stephen Miller are. FASCISTS to the core.
Trump is a sick man!
Lots of people are upset. He just doesn't care. His staff is spinning his deranged hatred as a reasonable statement, as they always do.
You are absolutely right. It’s appalling. I just heard about this about an hour ago and couldn’t believe it.
And it’s not off topic. It absolutely speaks to the topic. This is not a reaction that requires a partisan or party-specific response. It affects anyone and everyone regardless of their political stripes.
San Diego can lean more conservative, but according to Il Duce, they’re in the nuclear crosshairs. Happily so, by his reckoning.
You’re from Nebraska, which is the second – unintentional – point that’s not tangential. The Dems have rallied behind Dan Osborn, an Independent. I’ve heard him in an interview, and I think the coalition needs folks like him. I certainly don’t agree with everything he says, but I do believe he needs space under the tent.
It’s not the first time that he’s talked about a nuclear strike on an American city, but now he’s gotten more specific. The President ruminates on these things, stays up all night “truthing” or whatever it’s called. Now that Newsom has spoken out, it’s going to get worse.
Iran can’t hit us with a nuclear weapon of course, but given the fact that he’s threatened to pull FEMA response for blue states in the past, counter terrorism support for states not complying with requests to turn over voter rolls, and has a severely diminished stockpile of defensive weapons, I think the biggest threat is that he would deprioritize their defense in the event of an attack by an aggressor. Not that we should expect that, but we have a president who probably would do that. No other president would make someone like myself even have to consider such scenarios.
I am one of those Independents who can’t stand Trump but I am also leery of some Democratic positions. The Democratic Party is the vehicle we must use to rid ourselves of MAGA.
I appreciate your comment about the Dems being "the vehicle we must use to rid ourselves of MAGA". I'm a registered, lifelong Democrat, and while I'm excited about many of their programs, I'm clear-eyed about their weaknesses as well. One thing I know for sure: I will stay on my state and federal representatives to deliver on their promises.
I actually got the phrase about the Democratic Party being “the vehicle” from Sarah Longwell of The Bulwark. I am listening to her book How to Eat an Elephant. I recommend it.
But what are those alleged "weaknesses"?
Imho we on the left have become WAY too cynical.
We just criticize Democrats extremely carelessly. Not only do we not back up our criticism with solid arguments, we indulge (and for SO long already) in just claiming vague stuff the way you do here, without even THINKING of being precise in our criticism.
Cynicism on the left is one of the main reasons why we ended up here in the first place.
So with that... what are those "weaknesses" more precisely?
Sheesh, slow your roll! I don't think saying that the Dems have weaknesses is extreme criticizing! Believe me, I know what extreme criticizing is as I've been doing it regarding Trump and the Republican party for a steady 12 years. Also, I'm not about to add to a quick acknowledgenent reply with details of what I mean by weaknesses. Every person, animal, organization, etc. on earth, in this dimension and time has weaknesses. We do not live in perfection.
See, you're doing it again: you blindly repeat that "Dems have weaknesses," you even add that you are "clear-eyed" about that, and then... give NO concrete example of such a weakness, let alone arguments to prove that this would be true. Even after someone asks you to give at least one example.
Why not?
Why just spread more cynicism and blind Dem-bashing? You really think that's needed, especially today?
I learned not to take the bait. His handle means “Excuse Us We Don’t Talk Back”. It’s true, he doesn’t talk back, he condescends and likes to poke the bear. A troll really.
He just fiercely defends the Dems, refusing to acknowledge their serious shortcomings. And how they, too have failed the Working and Middle Class in many ways. Which is why so many were sent hurtling into the arms of Rump. Millions of whom were former Democrats.
He requests examples from others, yet offers none himself for his ardent support of the Democratic Party.
Fortunately, he’s really the only one I have ever seen here behaving this way.
There is a large group on the left that doesn't vote for the Democratic candidate, because it isn't the candidate they liked the most. That is a significant weakness. We have weaknesses in messaging. We sometimes lack the courage to stand up for groups when they are unfairly marginalized by the right. We sometimes lack the courage to stand up TO groups that are demanding unreasonable concessions to earn their vote. Etc. Fortunately, we don't have the most significant weakness: we don't have a leader of our party that has completely dissolved our morals, ideologies, and ability to make American lives better. That should make everyone in the middle and left very proud.
In a primary, sometimes your candidate wins and sometimes they lose. We have to accept that and continually put in efforts to bring people closer to our ideals. Just remember, plenty of others doing the same thing.
I’ve never heard this. Interesting. I VBNMW. Because I have no other choice. Well I had Bernie, but the Dems buried him—twice. Because they have become too establishment themselves. And way too Corporate.
FYI for everyone concerned about AIPAC/Israel funding our representatives. Keep in mind, many of these people are excellent representatives and it costs money to stay in office. Some of the names may surprise you while others won’t, I’m sure. The point is right now is to hang together or we shall surely hang separately. I think old Ben Franklin is credited with having said that. Keep in mind, those guys were having many of the same arguments we are having today in spite of the fact that they would be considered and treated as traitors to the crown.
https://whofundsmyrep.com/rankings/democrats
Amen
What Democratic positions more precisely?
Name the Democratic party positions you are uncomfortable with, it is not hard to be specific, it is too easy to just say you are “leery of some Democratic positions.”
So many registered Democrats (and Independents) have become intellectually lazy. Dem-bashing seems to have become their favorite daily exercise.
It's KILLING democracy itself.
In the meantime, more than 100 historians have proven that the Biden administration was actually one of the most productive of all US presidencies.
But who still cares about facts... ?
I do believe this—no, I KNOW this about the Biden Administration! Accusations and calling people intellectually lazy is no way to start a conversation. This is the polar opposite of what this very article is about…El-Sayed went into enemy territory to talk with people who are completely propagandized by that very platform. He spoke with reason, calmness and clarity. He didn’t go on there and tell them how “intellectually lazy” they are.
Damn dude, try a different tack. The idea is to reach people, converse, exchange ideas…not condescend and attack.
Intellectual laziness is real. Why would we try to put our head in the sand rather than tackling the problem and solving it?
As to El-Sayed: yes, when talking with "the enemy", diplomacy is THE priority. But here, we're talking among ourselves. So here we can and should get real, no? If not here, then where... ?
Also "intellectual laziness" refers to an ACTION (or whole series of actions). Not any particular person. It's precisely the tendency to take disagreements personally these days/years that makes real debates impossible.
They also don't have to be specific. No one owes you that.
But we all owe it to society as a whole and democracy.
Individualism and democracy are not compatible.
THE key rule of engaging in a real debate is that you ALWAYS accept to not just spout "personal opinions" (which often are just what the dominant culture tells us to think) but to accept to fact-check your OWN opinions, as soon as someone asks you, by showing evidence that backs them up.
If YOU make the claim, YOU need to tell us what evidence you discovered that proves it.
Someone who disagrees with that claim by definition cannot do it, because IF he discovered the same evidence, he might not disagree in the first place.
A democracy vitally requires constant education by and for citizens. That practice is almost entirely gone today, including on the left.
I think a little history is required here. I. Have been registered Republican who often voted democratic. The Bill Clinton abortion platform turned me off.
Since January 6th I am an independent which is nice in California
What Democratic positions more precisely?
Read The Hartman Report this morning
Thx Joy! I’d never heard of it. Just did what you suggested, and now I’m a subscriber. 😃
What does it say? And why do you believe that it is true?
Because she is supposed to copy and paste it for YOU. I see, but she (annd others) are intellectually lazy. M’k. Who’s being being emotional rather than rational now? 🤔
You can’t just go check it out? That’s what I did. I’d never even heard of it. Great stuff. I just subscribed.
Alice I had enough with his comments I mute his voice every time he is being interviewed 🧐😥
Huh? Who’s comments?
Trump's, I presume (see OP)?
Just another reason why we need more than just 2 viable parties. For that to work we need to get rid of the Electoral College. The Democrats have always created a platform at their conventions. The Republicans in the Trump era didn’t bother with a platform. It was literally “whatever Trump wants.” This week in Illinois RepublicanJim Durkin, former House Minority Leader in the state legislature, endorsed Democratic governor JB Pritzger over his Republican opponent Darren Bailey. It’s an encouraging sign that support for Trump is fading and affecting elections at all levels.
Independent until the two-party system is improved. I don't align well with either party, but I don't fault them for that - we need to find a better way to distinguish different groups in a coalition so that moderate Republicans can feel comfortable working/voting with moderate dems. That's not meant to be a slight against Progressives - I just think it's a shame that the entire party is viewed from the same lens, when it's a WIDE range of viewpoints.
Sign me up Alice! I’m with you!
Reread what Adam wrote. We can have those discussions later. Right now the goal is to recognize the collective danger that Trump poses and join together to start getting a rope around his(fill in the blank)to stop him from any further damage.
Well said. Perfect example is the coalition of countries that got together to stop Hitler. Like you said we need countries on are side, something Hegsbreath doesn’t understand.
Yes. There was once a time when there were liberal and progressive Republicans and conservative Democrats. The result was a much more dynamic process of building ad-hoc coalitions to address particular things. Right now we need a coalition to preserve democracy.
Bravo 👏🏻
Great column. We surely need a large and wide ranging coalition of people who want to ensure that democracy reigns here. A coalition of any and all who believe in our constitution and the rule of law. A coalition of people who remember what is what like when their immigrant families came here and struggled for a better way of life. A coalition of people who believe that our allies are valuable and essential to preserving a just peace. A coalition of people who believe that stealing, violating ethics standards and self dealing in office goes against the oath of office one took for the privilege of holding public office. These basic tenets are neither right nor left . I’ve said before that this country has a big tent open to many different people and opinions . There is a place for anyone and everyone of good will.
As a progressive, I cannot agree more!
Yes, we absolutely need an "uncomfortably big coalition".
Next, we need to get comfortable with disagreements and learn to engage in real, respectful debates rather than running away as soon as someone disagrees with us.
Recently a fellow progressive told me, when we disagreed about an actually pretty minor thing, "I choose not to engage on this topic any further". That was before she gave ANY argument backing up her claim.
This is not okay. For far too long, progressives have forgotten how to HONOR healthy disagreements and engage with them. That is on us. No MAGA cult ever forced us to do so. It's also on us to urgently drop this intellectual laziness and get real again, especially now that democracy itself depends on it!
Actually listening to our disagreements means we might learn something new.
Exactly! And ALL of us, since none of us possess The Truth.
If we stop engaging in debates about politics at home, at work, at church etc, we contribute to a collective dumbing down of society as a whole, which cannot but lead to political and other disasters.
Democracy vitally needs disagreements AND constant debating of those disagreements.
Not a culture that instead values emotional reactivity...
Like knife sharpening--we need to hone our thoughts and POVs against a rough edge to get the best results.
Exactly! All too often today, the media claim that the US is so "divided", but that seems to mostly refer to the fact that there are a lot of disagreements.
Disagreements are GOOD, in a democracy - including inside one party (even more so when there are only two parties).
Real "division" only arises when we refuse to back up our claims with arguments and evidence or adopt a "post-truth" attitude where everyone has the "right" to believe whatever they want, no questions asked.
Example: apparently Jennifer Dyke already blocked me (making it impossible for me to see and therefore reply to other people replying to my posts in the same thread), ONLY because I asked for arguments backing up her claims (as a fellow Democrat, moreover).
That literally divides us, and can never lead to anything good.
I totally agree we need respectful debates. This morning I read about 2 men in Ohio in a dog park whose disagreement about our president ended in gunfire and now potentially prison for an 80 year old man. The 3rd man trying to break up the fight said he doubted that it actually changed either of their opinions. We have to do better and have meaningful conversations about our thoughts and ideas.
Adam, you're so right when you say "none of those differences are as big as the threat in front of us"... you're either for democracy and the rule of law, or you're not ... I welcome anyone for the first one!
Thank you Adam for this post, and for illuminating the need Dr. El-Sayid talks about, in building a broader coalition. I also appreciate Dr El-Sayid’s reference to the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Although Dr. El-Sayid mis-attributed a specific quote to Dr. King, the legacy of Dr. King was all about inclusion. In 1960, there were people in the civil rights movement who disagreed with his commitment to nonviolence. When challenged, Dr King said, “There can be unity when there isn’t uniformity.” His point was that people could differ over how to pursue change while still unite in the struggle for it.
The orange felon is a Traitor! A President telling our enemy to take out our country and its citizens.
Where are the cabinet members and congress rebuking him?
Traitor!
This is why the 25th Amendment was passed.
If this doesn't meet the definition of high crimes to convict his impeachment I don't know what does.
These people are and have been committing treason against The United States. I do not see any other way to look at this. There is no way any of the other Presidents would have made such a statement. Taking out an American city? Good God.
Well, if the spineless and anti-Constitution Republican "party" didn't have a problem with Trump's failed coup, nor with electing him in direct violation of the 14th Amendment, nor with confirming his Klown Kar Kabinet, nor with him assuming Article I powers, nor with him straight-up stealing from our Treasury, nor with him taking emoluments for the 6 years in the Oval, nor with him fielding a Gestapo that kills Americans and others in the street with impunity, nor with Bribe Jet One/East Wing-Epstein Ballroom/Reflecting Pool/Arc de Pedo/campaign ads on the taxpayer dollar/kidnapping a foreign leader and making his nation a colony to extract oil and gold from, threatening ALLIES with annexation or invasion, backstabbing Ukraine and NATO, removing sanctions on Russia as they give satellite and targeting info to Iran to kill our troops, gutting the government, .......
I would encourage everyone to find a bridging organization and learn how to talk across the aisle (or even within your aisle). I moderate workshops for Braver Angels and I see the magic that happens when we lean into the discomfort and learn to disagree better. Let’s make a bigger tent where all perspectives are welcomed and disagreement leads to better solutions, not more contempt.
Thanks, Adam, for this post. As a left-leaning independent, I am not always comfortable with Dem proposals, but we are facing a choice between democracy and dictatorship. That is not a choice. So, squabble about policy later, but right now it is essential the Democratic tent includes everyone who is taking a stand against the authoritarianism currently supported by what remains of the GOP. I grew up in a Goldwater-right Republican family, but by 1980 I voted for John Anderson, and I have been unimpressed by the two parties ever since. But that has not kept me ftom voting - ever - and has made me research the people for whom I have voted. It's only been since 2016 that I have voted only for Dems, since I've concluded anyone choosing to run as a Republican is demonstrating spectacularly bad judgment. This election and 2028 are too important to the continuance of our republic to vote for a Republican candidate in any race. I truly hope that a new Republican party devoid of the influence of trump (more importantly devoid of the Project 2025 cabal) emerges in the next few years so that we actually have options. But that's not the case this year.
Uh... so in 2010, you voted for a GOP Congress?
And you did so because you were "unimpressed" by what Obama and Democrats had achieved in the first two years?
If yes, why exactly did you do that?
Uh...no! I voted for Dems that year - how did you "divine" I voted for GOP? I just said I researched candidates to determine who I vote for. Still do.
You wrote "It's only been since 2016 that I have voted only for Dems". That logically entails that in 2010, you still voted for at least some Republicans, no?
Ah....I may have voted for a Rep in a local race. I don't remember. But since trump's first term, I have not found a GOP candidate in any race I could support because running as a GOP candidate means they accept trump - and that makes their judgment flawed.
Wow! So well stated and well reported! Thank you both Abdul El-Sayed and Adam Kinzinger for sharing this with We the People! Thank you!🇺🇸
Don’t forget that Pete Buttigieg went on Fox a lot to try to reach that audience. Syed is not the first one to do it. Pete needs to be acknowledged for that too.
There’s a phenomenon called the narcissism of small differences that addresses how like- minded groups can fragment over less important differences in values, preferences, opinions, issues etc.
Take as an example religious sects fighting over relatively minor differences in interpretations of scripture.
In a sense it’s losing sight of the forest for the trees. We need to be cognizant of this and strive to not let it divide us.
Currently in the world there is some form of universal healthcare in 54 out of 195 countries. Those numbers may be plus or minus one or two, but it does show that universal healthcare is something our country should work toward. There are a lot of progressive ideas that I do agree with, but there are also some that I do not agree with. You are right, Mr. Kinzinger, the party isn't the coalition. Right now, I would say that many of us whether we are republican, democrat or independent see that what we are fighting against is so much more than party politics. The Heritage Foundation's Project 2025 is probably about 75% done, and if we want to keep our Democracy, it cannot be allowed to come to completion. If that should happen, we can kiss our Democracy good-bye. Currently, America is being viewed as a country in collapse, divided and weak. It is sad that our once great country is being viewed that way, and as far as I am concerned, the fault lies squarely on the shoulders of the man in the White House, his cabinet and all the republicans that have allowed him to destroy us. I will never stop fighting against authoritarianism. Thank you. That was an excellent post today, Mr. Kinzinger!
Well put, Adam.